The case of Jim and the Indians. Bernard Williams wrote this case to bring out some of the problems in one of the ethical theories we are studying in this module, but we should examine this case through the lens of our various ethical theories.

1. Think about this case, and then describe how a Utilitarian, Kantian, virtue ethicist, and rights theorist would respond to this case. (That is, what would each of them tell Jim to DO and WHY?)
2. Then, tell me which one of them you think is the most reasonable, and why.